Young Americans Still Want Same Number of Kids, Just Not Right Now
TUESDAY, Jan. 17, 2023 (HealthDay News) -- When birth rates fall in the United States, experts try to figure out what’s happening.
The fertility rate is at its lowest since the 1970s -- 1.71 per woman, according to a new study.
But it's not that young people today don't want children, new research suggests. In fact, they want about as many as their parents had.
Instead, young Americans may simply be having more difficulty achieving life goals in order to have kids, said study co-author Sarah Hayford, director of the Ohio State University Institute for Population Research.
"You see a lot of things of like, 'Oh, young people just aren't interested in having children' or 'young people have better things to do.' And we don't find that," Hayford said. "We find that young people are interested in having children and people want children. They're planning to have children. It’s just other things that are making it hard to carry out those plans."
The U.S. fertility rate peaked during the post-World War II baby boom, at 3.58 in 1958 and reached a low of 1.77 in 1972. After a rebound, birth rates plummeted during the Great Recession starting in 2008 and continued to drop even after, Hayford said.
For the study, Hayford and co-author Karen Benjamin Guzzo, director of the Carolina Population Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, used data from the U.S. National Survey of Family Growth.
They looked at 13 groups of women and 10 groups of men born between the 1960s and 2000s. Participants were asked whether they planned to have kids and how many they expected to have.
On average, women born between 1995 and 1999 who responded to that question when they were 20 to 24 years old said they wanted 2.1 children. That was close to what women born in 1965 to 1969 wanted at the same age, 2.2.
The percentage who said they didn't plan to have kids rose from about 5%-8% in the 1960s and 1970s to about 8%-16% in the 1990s and 2000s. But researchers said that change alone didn't explain the declining birthrate.
One factor is a reduction in unintended births, researchers said.
The study also found evidence that as people age, they change their minds, reducing the number of kids they want.
Finances and taking longer to find a romantic partner can explain some of the delays, Hayford said.
"Obviously in the United States it's expensive to have children, so people want to wait until they're financially in a place where they feel like they can manage having children, and that's taking a longer time," Hayford said.
"It's harder to buy a house or to find a stable place to rent," she added. "Housing feels like it takes longer to line up."
The delay may mean that people who have trouble conceiving will have less time to manage the problem. That can make it harder to fulfill the goal of having two or three children, Hayford said.
Jennifer Barber, a professor of sociology and senior scientist in the Kinsey Institute at Indiana University, reviewed the findings.
"I agree with their conclusion that people are just preferring later childbearing," Barber said. "And when you delay it, you're taking the risk that maybe you're not going to get to do it."
This delay in childbearing may dovetail with another trend -- young people having an extended transition to adulthood because it takes longer to establish a household or a career. As a result, people move back in with their parents for a while, Barber said.
"I do think what you're seeing is this delayed preference for delayed childbearing does really reflect young people's desire to wait to form families and to wait to have kids," Barber said. "It reflects their uncertainty about whether they have the stuff it takes to form a family."
Babies are expensive for middle-class people, Barber noted, highlighting day care as a major cost.
"As long as people are struggling to make ends meet, you’re going to keep seeing these same things," she said.
The study also notes that barriers exist in the United States around economics, child care and health insurance.
"Forming your family is one of the most important things that contributes to our well-being over the long run," Barber said. "Being able to achieve the family that you want has huge implications just for individual humans about their happiness and their well-being and their health."
This all matters in a bigger societal way, too.
If there are not enough young people to work and pay into Social Security, there won’t be enough money for retirees to draw from it, for example. In terms of consumer markets, there may not be enough people to buy goods.
Some of those problems can be managed by changing the retirement age or increasing immigration rates, Hayford said.
Research for the new study was done prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, and looking at the impact of that on fertility will happen in the coming months and years.
Most Americans do have children eventually, Hayford said, including about 80% of women who will have at least one.
"Having children is a really important life decision for a lot of people," she said. "It's important for people's values and the kind of person they want to be, the kind of life they want to lead, and it also has really important economic consequences for the way people approach work."
The findings were recently published in the journal Population and Development Review.
The U.S. Census Bureau has more on fertility rates.
SOURCES: Sarah Hayford, PhD, professor, sociology, and director, Institute for Population Research, Ohio State University, Columbus; Jennifer Barber, PhD, professor, sociology, and senior scientist, Kinsey Institute, Indiana University, Bloomington; Population and Development Review, Jan. 10, 2023